Wicked, Part 1, 2024, Movie Review: Comparing the Movie to the Novel

Saturday, November 23, 2024 is National Fibonacci DayAt 12:30pm: I walked across the street to the movie theater. I bought my ticket and went inside that theater room #5, which ...
The movie, Wicked Part 1, was an interesting musical, but many things were changed. It is what I expected. Hollywood always changes movies based on novels. It seemed different from what I read in the novel about the story. For one thing, Alphaba’s mother was white and vain in the novel, but she is black in this movie. Alphaba’s sister didn’t have arms in the novel, and she had a nanny with her; in the movie, Alphaba’s sister is in a wheelchair and by herself. But her stepfather or her mother’s husband already gives her the magic shoes. In the movie, Alphaba’s sister was very white in the novel, similar to Galinda and the rest of the students. But in the movie, Alphaba’s sister looks Latina, and the school looks multiracial.

Saturday, November 23, 2024 is National Fibonacci DayAt 12:30pm: I walked across the street to the movie theater. I bought my ticket and went inside that theater room #5, which was empty because I was a little early. I played with my iPhone until 1:20pm. The room filled up.

The movie, Wicked Part 1, was an interesting musical, but many things were changed. It is what I expected. Hollywood always changes movies that are based on novels. It seemed different from what I read in the novel about the story. For one thing, Alphaba’s mother was white and vain in the novel, but she is black in this movie. Alphaba’s sister didn’t have arms in the novel, and she had a nanny with her; in the movie, Alphaba’s sister is in a wheelchair and by herself. But her stepfather or her mother’s husband already gave her the magic shoes. In the movie, Alphaba’s sister was very white in the novel, similar to Galinda and the rest of the students. But in the movie, Alphaba’s sister looks Latina, and the school looks multiracial.

The movie appeared to be a different era from the novel because the movie had different cultures and different sexual orientation students, which seemed very current. But the sorcery college reminded me of a cross between Harry Potter school and scenes from Disneyland. The wizard, played by Jeff Goldblum, reminded me of Walt Disney as well as a little bit of Willy Wonka. Galinda, played by Ariana Grande, always dressed in pink. Her bedroom was filled with pink. She was almost similar to Barbie. But I remember her saying something about "Devil Wears Prada." when she was inside her dorm room, chatting with her friends. I feel she was referring this devil to herself because of all the expensive clothes she owned, and she took over 75% over the dorm room, giving Alphaba only a 25% corner to call her own space. It also explains that Galinda is two-faced, willing to do anything for her future materialistic success.

Some ideas from the novel were still used in the movie. Alphaba’s hatred for Madame Morrible and the Wizard was displayed in the movie because she realized that they are both corrupt liars, trying to use her and her powers to destroy the animals and the earth for political reasons. She refused to be a part of their plan. At the end of the movie, she flew off on her broom. Galinda refused to go with Alphaba because Galinda sold out to the Wizard and Madame Morrible for money and materialism. Alphaba seems down-to-earth because she has a strong interest in helping the animals and Animals.

Fiyero is in this movie, and Galinda pursues hm and they date, but he seems more interested in Alphaba. In this Wicked Part 1, Alphaba is best friends with Galinda, who is also her roommate, and she becomes friends with Fiyero. But in the novel, there were more people at the school, and they all often partied together and hung out together at different places, like many college student excursions. In the novel, Galinda had her clique, but Alphaba mostly hung out with her goat professor friend.

Therefore, Wicked Part 1 appears to be modernized for current society. The story in the novel felt like it was taking place in the fifties or even earlier, because it felt old-fashioned and rural.

I had more fun reading the book because the novel was similar to a soap opera. Something crazy always happened to the characters to push the story forward to the next level. The book was a page-turner. In the movie, when the police went to the college to take away the goat professor because animals no longer can teach and they were losing their rights to exist, it was sad but different from the novel, which was even worse. In the novel, the goat professor was found dead, or murdered, because he was working on a cure for something. Alphaba knew Madame Morrible and the Wizard had collaborated in getting him killed, which is why she drops out of the college and moves to a downtown area to meditate and be in solitude. Her friends called her a conspiracy theorist, but she knew it was true.

But I don’t remember Alphaba turning monkeys into flying monkeys in the novel. At least the movie kept Alphaba's true character, which was an intelligent activist who wants to help the animals. She wasn’t wicked. Rather, she was being demonized by Madame Morrible and the Wizard because she didn’t want to a part of the corrupt plans. So, they labelled her as wicked and made everyone hate her or be afraid of her. But her friends at the college knew she wasn’t like that.

The movie was still interesting, but it had its own Hollywood agenda, promoting certain current ideas to the masses. Galinda's monochromatic pink outfits as well as her aspirations to be Devil Wears Prada, and Alphaba's monochromatic black outfits. Although the movie was three-hour long, it had good pacing and it didn’t lag. When I walked outside, I noticed it had rained when I was watching the movie. When I walked in my neighborhood, I noticed lots of black birds were hanging out by my townhomes entrance area, waiting for something.

Avatar photo

Fifi Leigh

BA in Social Science from UCI, MBA from WebsterU, and Computer Graphic Design from PlattCollege. I self-published 2 novels on LULU.com. I was born in Edinburgh, Scotland but raised in America. I am a Vegan/Vegetarian and into Animal Rights. https://fashion-tips288.webnode.page
View all posts by Fifi Leigh

Featured Writers

Entertainment

Stories that Stir Souls: Illuminating the Path of Storytelling’s Influence

Storytelling: timeless art connecting people through narratives. From prehistoric times to modern tech, it educates, preserves culture, and inspires a better future. Crucial in bridging divides, it reminds us of our shared humanity.
Avatar photo
Yashasvy Singh
Storytelling: timeless art connecting people through narratives. From prehistoric times to modern tech, it educates, preserves culture, and inspires a better future. Crucial in bridging divides, it reminds us of our shared humanity.
Opinions

How I Lost and Found My Voice

"Initially, I changed my Malawian accent to fit in. But I learned my voice mattered, and my roots made me unique. Through struggles, I found my true self by embracing my Malawian identity. My journey is chronicled in my books, 'What Kind of Girl?' and 'Some Kind of Girl.'"
caroline Kautsire
Caroline Kautsire
how i lost and found my voice
Opinions

Nurturing Values In Children Through Storytelling

How storytelling shapes young minds, instilling empathy and resilience. Explore the power of narratives in nurturing values in children.
Devanshi Joshi
Devanshi Joshi
Entertainment

From Poetic Pause to Professional Power: The Journey of Emotional Resilience

Moving With Meaning offers guidance in emotional resilience, from introspective reflection to assertive leadership. Through coaching and the 3C Approach, we empower professionals to navigate challenges with grace and determination. Whether early, mid, or late career, we support you in finding purpose and direction in every step of your journey.
author, life coach, and the driving force behind Moving With Meaning LLC
Krystal Clark
Moving With Meaning offers guidance in emotional resilience, from introspective reflection to assertive leadership. Through coaching and the 3C Approach, we empower professionals to navigate challenges with grace and determination. Whether early, mid, or late career, we support you in finding purpose and direction in every step of your journey.

More in Interviews

The author Gabor Holch: Worldwide business leaders who try to comprehend China’s unavoidable impact on their livelihoods often ignore the most important voices: those of expatriate managers with years of experience in the country. Based on interviews with China-based corporate executives over five years, Dragon Suit brings to life the country’s swarming cities, recent economic tsunami, unstoppable middle class.

Finding a catchy book title is a headache, says Gabor Holch

Interview with Gabor Holch, author of "Dragon Suit": Explores expat executives' journey in China's business world, revealing both success and failure stories, reflecting on China's economic evolution and global impact.
first aid kit is an essential part when you choose bike / MTB for riding.

Stefan Eberharter: I always bring my first aid kit with me

Meet Stefan Eberharter, a MTB pro rider who got an excellent skills and training of downhill and other important bike riding skills that will ...
Do you love riding a motorcycle? If so, this article is for you, and if you are a Harley Devidson fan, you must read this interview with Maldita before purchasing one or if you already own one.

Maldita: “I try to travel and discover different cultures”

Do you love riding a motorcycle? If so, this article is for you, and if you are a Harley Davidson fan, you must read this interview with Maldita before purchasing one or if you already own one.